According to the information provided, a joint center will be established on the territory of Azerbaijan and in the newly captured areas. The exact location of the center has not been announced yet, but “Aqdam” seems to be one of the possible options.
The task of this joint center is to monitor the proper implementation of the ceasefire agreement in Nagorno-Karabakh. The establishment of a joint Turkish-Russian center in line with clause 5 of the Nagorno-Karabakh ceasefire agreement. Clause 5 of the ceasefire agreement states: “In order to increase the effectiveness of control over the implementation of the agreements by the Parties to the conflict, a peacekeeping center will be deployed to control the ceasefire.”
The Kremlin previously stated that no agreement has been reached on the presence of Turkish troops in Nagorno-Karabakh. However, the Kremlin seems to be referring to the presence of Turkish troops alongside Russian military patrols inside the Nagorno-Karabakh region, not to their presence at the joint monitoring center. Turkish Defense Minister also stated that Turkey will be present in the joint peacekeeping force to monitor the implementation of the ceasefire agreement in Nagorno-Karabakh.
However, later, the Russian foreign minister, Sergey Lavrov said: Turkish monitoring center on Karabakh will operate remotely using drones and Turkish observers will not travel to Karabakh.
In the future, it will be determined whether Turkish troops will be physically present at the new Karabakh border or not.
The peacekeepers, including Russian military police, are currently stationed in the Lachin corridor.
According to information provided by the Russian Ministry of Defense, 1960 Russian peacekeepers will be stationed in Nagorno-Karabakh and their main tasks include: – Collecting information on ceasefire violations and communicating this information to the command of the peacekeepers – Maintaining the safety of free transit and transport – Suppression of illegal actions against the civilian population
There will also be 16 observation posts in the Nagorno-Karabakh region to monitor the implementation of the Karabakh peace agreement. The map below shows the location of these 16 observation posts in the Karabakh area. The Red Triangles are the site of Russian observation posts and red dotted are the main patrol areas for Russian peacekeepers.
Location of Russian observation posts in Nagorno-Karabakh
The map below shows the Lachin corridor. The red triangles of the Russian temporary posts are shown, the black dashes shows the Lachin corridor area.
Map of Lachin corridor
According to maps published by the Russian Ministry of Defense, the Russian zones of responsibility are divided into northern and southern parts, and the map below shows Russia’s operational area and observation posts in the southern part.
Prior to the agreement, three other ceasefires had been announced in Nagorno-Karabakh, which none of them lasted. But Russia’s more serious entry as a major player in the Fourth ceasefire ended the fragile agreements and ceasefires in the Nagorno-Karabakh.
The Azerbaijan-Armenia peace agreement has nine main clauses and is summarized as follows: 1- Complete cessation of clashes and stop in the current positions 2- Delivery of Agdam region to Azerbaijan 3 and 4 – Deployment of Russian forces in Nagorno-Karabakh 5- Establishing a center to monitor the implementation of the agreement 6- Delivery of Kalbajar and Lachin regions to Azerbaijan 7- Return of refugees to Karabakh 8- Exchange of prisoners and corpses 9- Establishing a transit corridor between western areas of Azerbaijan and Nakhchivan region
At first glance, this agreement may seem like a complete victory for Azerbaijan and a defeat for Armenia, or at least Azerbaijan has achieved what it wanted from Nagorno-Karabakh. However, with a further examination of this agreement and the deployment of Russian forces in the Nagorno-Karabakh region, many questions and ambiguities arise about the fate of this region, which we will examine on a map to better understand this agreement.
– Green hached are regions that scheduled to be returned to the Republic of Azerbaijan within a certain period of time. The Kalbajar region will be handed over to the Republic of Azerbaijan by November 15, the Agdam region by November 20, the Lachin region and the occupied territories of Gazakh by December December 1. The important point about this issue is that “not” all the districts(Rayons) of Agdam, Kalbajar and Lachin, but also the areas that were occupied by the Armenian forces outside the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Region” will be returned to Azerbaijan. For example, the eastern half of Rayon Kalbajar is located in the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast” and these areas will remain under the control of Armenian forces and only the western half of Kalbajar will be handed over to Azerbaijan. The same is true about a small part of western areas of Aqdam Rayon too. In other words, the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast” mechanism is still in place in these areas. Regarding the two occupied points in the Gazakh region in northwestern Azerbaijan, it is noteworthy that despite the agreement to return the two points to the Republic of Azerbaijan, the next statement issued by Russia does not mention the status of these two points. And how to solve this issue is unknown. It is said that the original text of the agreement has been leaked and in the next version, which is the original version, this part has been modified and deleted.
– Blue hached are areas where 1,960 Russian peacekeepers with 90 armored vehicles and 380 vehicles and special equipment will be stationed. If we look closely at the deployment of Russian forces in the Nagorno-Karabakh region, it is quite clear that these forces will be stationed exactly inside and on the borders of the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast.” This means that in fact the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous” will be recognized for Armenia and will remain in the possession of Armenian forces. Although this issue is not mentioned in the text of the agreement, but in practice it will mean that. In addition to this issue, it should be added that: The text of the agreement states that the Russian peacekeeping forces will remain in the region for 5 years, and if there is no particular problem, this 5-year period will be extended for another 5 years. And these courses will continue indefinitely. Clearly, this also confirms and extends the survival of autonomy in Nagorno-Karabakh. Nonetheless, these areas are separate from the areas captured by the Azerbaijani army during the recent operation in the Nagorno-Karabakh region. If we look closely at the southern regions of Karabakh, and especially the southern regions of the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast”, it is clear that the Azerbaijani forces have taken control of a small part of the southern “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast” and most of the achievements are in areas occupied by Armenian forces outside the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast.”
– On the map, the progress of Azerbaijan army in the Nagorno-Karabakh region is shown in yellow. Obviously, this is a very good victory because the Republic of Azerbaijan has been able to liberate almost all the southern regions of Karabakh, but on the other hand, this should not be too bad for Armenia either; Because in general, the areas around the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast”, both in the north and in the south of Karabakh, are officially and internationally part of the territory of Azerbaijan, and the Armenian forces, which occupied the areas around the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast” in the last 28 yeasr, are now giving the lands to its owner in the south by military force, and in the north by the recent agreement. Therefore, Armenia can consider the occupied territories around the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast” as a negotiating card, which it is now handing over, and in return will take over most of the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast” region. The Republic of Azerbaijan has also achieved its goal to return the 7 occupied cities of Karabakh. Nevertheless, it is worth mentioning that Azerbaijan demands all of Nagorno-Karabakh, and with the current situation and the field conditions, this issue has not been achieved. Because most of the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast” with the support of Russia remains under the control of Armenian forces for an indefinite period of time.
Another important issue that should be considered is Russia’s opposition to the presence of Turkish forces in Nagorno-Karabakh. The President of Azerbaijan stated in a televised speech on the agreement to end the war in Nagorno-Karabakh that, in addition to the Russian peacekeeping forces, the Turkish peacekeeping forces will also be stationed in Nagorno-Karabakh. But the Kremlin said in a statement that the issue was not mentioned in the agreement and that the leaders of Russia, Armenia and Azerbaijan had not agreed on the deployment of Turkish troops in the Nagorno-Karabakh region. According to the statement, the presence of Turkish troops in the Nagorno-Karabakh region is virtually rejected, and this implicitly confirms Russia’s support for the continuation of autonomy in the remaining areas of the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast.” In general, the presence of Turkish forces in Nagorno-Karabakh or direct land links between Turkey and the Republic of Azerbaijan is a strategic threat to Russia, a threat that reduces Russia’s influence and hegemony in the Caucasus and the Caspian Sea and then in Central Asia. In other words.it will increase Turkey’s power and influence in the region; This is definitely against the wishes and policy of Russia. Therefore, Russia is trying to prevent this from happening. Russia’s opposition to the official deployment of Turkish forces in Nagorno-Karabakh can be interpreted from this perspective.
– Another important issue is the establishment of a new transit and transportation route between Stepanakert and Armenia along the Lachin corridor for three years, as well as the establishment of a safe transit route between the west of the Republic of Azerbaijan and the Nakhchivan region through Armenia. These routes also will be secured by Russian FSB forces. Comparing these two routes, it can be concluded that Armenia provides Azerbaijan with a safe transportation route in exchange for a safe transportation route to Stepanakert. This also means that Azerbaijan implicitly accepts the autonomy of Nagorno-Karabakh in exchange for Azerbaijan’s direct connection to the Nakhchivan region. On the map, the new transit and transportation route between Stepanakert and Armenia has been marked with a red arrow and the possible communication route between Azerbaijan and Nakhchivan has been marked with a yellow arrow. Nonetheless, there is a railroad in the south of Armenia and near the borders of Iran, the use of which can also be on the agenda.
– Another important issue is the return of refugees to Nagorno-Karabakh. During the Karabakh war, Azeri residents in various parts of Karabakh, including Khojaly, were driven out of the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast” or Armenians expelled from the southern part of Nagorno-Karabakh, such as Hadrut, during the last two months of fighting; The mechanism for the return of the displaced persons is not explicitly mentioned in the agreement, and so far none of the officials of the parties have commented on it. The city of Shusha is an example of this problem; Shusha is now under the control of the Republic of Azerbaijan, and if this clause of the agreement is to be implemented, Armenians and Azeris must be present together in Shusha, which seems impossible in the current situation.
In general, this agreement, beyond what the parties claim is neither an absolute victory nor an absolute defeat Rather, so far each side has achieved a certain amount of its own goals; The difference is that Azerbaijan has achieved somewhat slightly more than Armenia. The Republic of Azerbaijan acquired the territories around the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast” (plus parts of the south of the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast”) after 28 years. On the other hand, Armenia gained autonomy (at least nominally) and a presence in the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast”. The Republic of Azerbaijan achieved a direct land route with the Nakhchivan region, and on the opposite side of Armenia achieved a direct land route to the center of the “Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast”, the city of Stepanakert.
Regarding the future of the Nagorno-Karabakh region, according to the existing agreement, there are many issues and ambiguities that are not mentioned at least in the text of the contract, and this issue will be problematic in the future and will bring an uncertain future for Nagorno-Karabakh. At present, with Russia’s direct entry into Nagorno-Karabakh, its influence and pressure on the region has increased, and on the other hand, important political developments are taking place in Armenia, and the lines of contact and conflict will always be a place for escalating tensions. Anything is possible in the future, just as Azerbaijan recaptured Nagorno-Karabakh after 28 years of renewal, it is not unlikely that Armenia will pursue a similar policy towards Azerbaijan, or even the odds prepare conditions for the continuation of the Azerbaijani army operation in Nagorno-Karabakh.
In his statement, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan described the agreement as a difficult one. “I have signed an agreement with the presidents of Russia and Azerbaijan to end the war in Nagorno-Karabakh, which is difficult for all of us,” he said. Nikol Pashinyan added :This ceasefire is very painful for our people and for myself. This is not a victory, but it will not be a defeat unless you acknowledge that you have lost. We will never admit that we have lost and this will be the beginning of the era of national unity for us. I kneel before the martyrs of all of you. I bow to all the soldiers, officers, generals and volunteers who defended our homeland with their lives.”
The text of the agreement is as follows: (Direct translation from the Russian text)
“We, President of the Republic of Azerbaijan I. G. Aliyev, Prime Minister of the Republic of Armenia N. V. Pashinyan and President of the Russian Federation V. V. Putin, have declared the following:
1- A complete ceasefire to all hostilities in the zone of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict are declared from 00:00 Moscow time on November 10, 2020. The Republic of Azerbaijan and the Republic of Armenia, hereinafter referred to as the “Parties”, will be stopped at their positions.
2- The Agdam region and the territories held by the Armenian Party in the Gazakh region of the Republic of Azerbaijan shall be returned to the Azerbaijan party until November 20, 2020.
3- Along the line of contact in Nagorno-Karabakh and along the Lachin corridor, a peacekeeping contingent of the Russian Federation will be deployed in the amount of 1,960 servicemen with small arms, 90 armored personnel carriers, 380 units of automobile and special equipment.
4- The peacekeeping contingent of the Russian Federation will be deployed in parallel with the withdrawal of the Armenian armed forces. The duration of the stay of the peacekeeping contingent of the Russian Federation is 5 years with automatic extension for the next 5-year periods, if none of the Parties declares 6 months before the expiration of the period of intention to terminate the application of this provision.
5- In order to increase the effectiveness of control over the implementation of the agreements by the Parties to the conflict, a peacekeeping center will be deployed to control the ceasefire.
6- The Republic of Armenia will return the Kalbajar region to the Republic of Azerbaijan by November 15, 2020, and the Lachin region by December 1, 2020, leaving behind the Lachin corridor (5 km wide), which will ensure the connection of Nagorno-Karabakh with Armenia and at the same time will affect the city of Shusha. By agreement of the Parties, in the next three years, a plan for the construction of a new traffic route along the Lachin corridor, providing communication between Stepanakert and Armenia, with the subsequent redeployment of the Russian peacekeeping contingent to protect this route will be determined. The Republic of Azerbaijan guarantees the safety of traffic along the Lachin corridor and the safety of citizens, vehicles and goods in both directions.
7- Internally displaced persons and refugees will return to the territory of Nagorno-Karabakh and adjacent areas under the control of the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Refugees.
8- The exchange of prisoners of war and other detainees and bodies of the dead will be carried out.
9- All economic and transport links in the region will be unblocked. The Republic of Armenia will provides transport links between the western regions of the Republic of Azerbaijan and the Nakhichevan Autonomous Republic in order to organize the unimpeded movement of citizens, vehicles and goods in both directions. Control over transport communication is will be carried out by the bodies of the Border Guard Service of the FSB of Russia. By agreement of the Parties, the construction of new transport communications linking the Nakhichevan Autonomous Republic with the western regions of Azerbaijan will be provided.”
November 2020 President of the Republic of Azerbaijan Prime Minister of the Republic of Armenia President of the Russian Federation
Following the announcement, angry people stormed the government building in Yerevan. The sound of gunfire was also heard in Republic Square in Yerevan. On the other hand, simultaneously with the announcement of the new agreement, the city of Baku, the capital of Azerbaijan, was attacked with two ballistic missiles. According to Azerbaijani officials, the two attacks were carried out in the Khirdalan and Sumqayit areas, and both missiles were intercepted and destroyed.
The Armenian Ministry of Defense announced that on Monday afternoon, November 10, a Russian Army Mi-24 helicopter was shot down by an anti-aircraft missile system in the border area near the town of Yeraskh.
Two Russian servicemen were killed and a third was wounded and taken to the 102nd Russian military base in Armenia.
Armenian sources claim that the Azerbaijani S-300 Zenit system in the Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic shot down the helicopter. However, the incident appears to have been caused by a MANPAD.
The town of Yeraskh of Rayon Ararat is bordered by the town of Hyderabad of Rayon Sedrak of the Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic of Azerbaijan. This region is also located near the border of Armenia, Turkey and Nakhchivan and is relatively close to the borders of Iran.
An hour later, Azerbaijan accepted responsibility and apologized for what happened to the Russian May-24 helicopter and announced its readiness to pay compensation to Russia. The Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry said in a statement that the incident was a tragic accident.
The moment a Russian helicopter was targeted near Yeraskh
– After several days of heavy conflicts Azerbaijan forces claimed strategic town Shusha. Although Armenia rejects the full control of Shusha by Azerbaijan but due to the field situation the town is in hands of Azerbaijan. However, heavy clashes between Azerbaijan and Armenian forces continue in the area.
– On 8 November, Azerbaijan president, Ilham Aliyev in a symbolic act appeared at Heydar Aliyev grave in military uniform and claimed Azerbaijan control on Shusha town.
– According to information provided by Ilham Aliyev, villages and areas Gobu Dilagarda, Yal Pirehmedli, Yuxari Yaglivend, Dilagarda, Seyid Mahmudlu, Elesgerli, Ashagi Guzdek, Govshalti, Mirzejamalli, Shekerjik, Merdinli, Shikhli, Garamemmedli, Dovletyarli, Hajili, Huseynbeyli, Sarajig in the Fuzuli district and Demirchiler, Chanagchi, Medetkend, Signaq, Shushakend, Mukhtar, Dashalti in the Khojaly district and Susanlig, Doni, Tug, Akaku, Azikh, Mets Taglar, Salaketin, Zogalbulag, Aragul, Tagavard, Boyuk Tagavard, Zerdanashen, Sheher in the Khojavend district and Huseynalilar, Soyudlu, Ashagi Sirik, Galajig, Mollahesenli, Esgerkhanli, Yukhari Nusus, Ashig Melikli, Niftalilar, Gerer, Chelebiler in the Jabrayil district and Yukhari Mollu, Ashagi Mollu, Khojik, Garamanli, Khendek, Hemzeli, Mahrizli, Hal, Balligaya, Ulashli, Tinli, Khojahan, Boyuneger, Garagoyunlu, Chereli in the Qubadli district and Kechikli, Ordekli, Sobu, Garagoz, Isgenderbeyli villages, Bartaz settlement, Bartaz strategic elevation (2300m), Sigirt elevation (1370m), Shukurataz elevation (2000m), additional 5 nameless strategic elevations in the Zangilan district and Gulebird, Sefiyan, Turkler in the Lachin district are claimed by Azerbaijan forces. It is noteworthy that some of these areas have been captured in days and weeks before. (shown by blue circle on the map.)
– Clashes between Azerbaijan and Armenian forces were ongoing south of Martuni.
– Conflict continues between Azerbaijan and Armenian forces in Karmir Shuka village on Fuzuli-Shusha road.
– From September 27 to November 9, as a result of provocations committed by Armenians, 93 civilians were killed, 407 injured. During this period, 3326 residential buildings, 504 civilian objects, 120 apartment buildings were damaged, according to the Prosecutor General’s Office of Azerbaijan.
– Turkish foreign and defense Ministers met with Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev in Baku.
– Armenian air defense systems shot down a Turkish Bayraktar TB2 drone.
– Azerbaijan artillery shelled Stepanakert(Khankendi) town last night and today morning several times.
– Following Azerbaijan forces advances in Shusha and cutting Stepanakert-Lachin road and conflict reached Stepanakert, some of Stepanakert inhabitants are fleeing toward Armenia. It is noteworthy that since Stepanakert road to Armenia is under fire by Azerbaijani forces and Kalbajar road is not very safe, some believe this footage is not very reliable.
In recent days, Azerbaijani forces have reached the important town of Shusha in the center of the Nagorno-Karabakh region and cut off the Stepanakert-Lachin route near Shusha several times. Although Armenian forces spoke of reopening the route and repelling Azeri forces, clashes continued around the town and along the road between the two sides.
On November 8, a video was released showing Armenian forces taking up positions at the northern entrance to the town of Shusha, where they were fighting close to Azerbaijani forces, and from the point of view of the clashes, Azerbaijani forces appeared to be inside Shusha.
Clashes at the northern entrance to Shusha
Later on November 8, the President of Azerbaijan, Ilham Aliyev, appeared in the Azerbaijani media and announced the control of the important town of Shusha by the Azerbaijani forces after 28 years.
According to the published images and evidence, the Azerbaijani forces have full control of Shusha, or in the worst scenario, most of the town is under the control of the Azerbaijani forces. On the other hand, the Armenian forces have started their counterattacks to retake Shusha, but considering the past experiences, the recapture of Shusha by the Armenian forces seems very unlikely.
– Clashes between the Azerbaijani and Armenian forces continue around Shusha and in the last 24 hours the lines of conflict have not changed significantly.
– Shusha-Lachin road is closed to the public by Armenia due to the presence and infiltration of Azerbaijani forces in the area.
– The Armenian Ministry of Defense announced the downing of four Azerbaijani drones in the Vardenis area inside Armenia.
– Armenian artillery targeted the Tartar and Shikharkh areas.
– According to the Armenian media, one person was killed and several others were wounded in an Azerbaijani artillery attack on the villages of Davit Bek and Agarak inside Armenia.
– The Azerbaijani army repulsed the attack of the Armenian forces on the Zangilan front.
– President of Azerbaijan Ilham Aliyev announced the control of Mirek and Kavdar villages of Jabrayil, Meshediismayilli and Shefibeyli villages of Zengilan, Basharat, Garakishiler and Garajalli of Qobadli.
– More companies stopped sending UAV equipment to Turkey.
The video shows moments of Azerbaijani forces approaching Shusha and being targeted by Armenian artillery. Examination of satellite images revealed that Azerbaijani forces were on the Lachin-Shusha road. Position of forces on the map
Currently, the Azerbaijani forces are near Shusha, 12 km from Stepanakert (Khankendi), the center of the Karabakh region.
This style of drone video has never been released by Armenia. Directing artillery fire by drones could be one of the reasons for the slowdown in the progress of the Azerbaijani army.
Armenia DM spokesperson said regarding Azerbaijan operation in south of Lachin: “Today at 10:30 local time at southeast of Lachin town Azerbaijan forces attacked again using IFVs. Artsakh army repelled the attack by destroying three tanks. At 12:55 Azerbaijan launched a new attack which was repelled again by losing two tanks and two vehicles. The conflict continues at this front.”
Shushan Stepanyan said that Azerbaijan commando and pioneer forces fought in this axis added: “After midnight, enemy sabotage group tried to claim Shusha road but faced Artsakh army and volunteer units resistance and retreated with heavy casualties.”
Today afternoon he reported that the Shusha-Lachin road is closed on civilians and said: “At the moment the forces are searching and cleansing sabotage groups of Azerbaijan. In this sense part of Shusha-Lachin road is closed to public.”
Considering these remarks, it seems Azerbaijan forces intent to cut Karabakh and Armenia road at two points of Lachin and Shusha simultaneously.
He said: “If PKK terrorists are not removed from the battlefield, there won’t be any peace.”
Criticizing Minsk group, he added: The group could not reclaim the occupied land from Armenia and Azerbaijan has the right to liberated its occupied land with war and we stand with our full strength beside this country and it’s our right.”
The remarks by the Turkish Defense Minister and Commander-in-Chief of the Turkish Armed Forces confirm the military intervention in the recent Karabakh war.
– According to the latest field information, Azerbaijani forces have reached the city of Shusha and heavy clashes between Azerbaijani special forces and Armenian forces continue in the region. This afternoon, pro-Azerbaijani media reported the control of the Dasalti area south of Shusha after 48 hours of heavy fighting.
– Armenian artillery targeted the Tartar, Fuzuli, Gadaby and Tovuz. Azerbaijan claimed that Armenia has used phosphorous bombs. Armenia, on the other hand, has accused Azerbaijan of using phosphorous bombs.
– Azerbaijani artillery targeted the city of Stepanakert (Khankendi).
– Clashes between Azerbaijani and Armenian forces continue in the south of Martuni (Khojavend).
– A unit of Azerbaijani special forces was ambushed by Armenian forces in Nagorno-Karabakh in the Karmir Shuka region. Among the items left were the uniforms of the Azerbaijani border guards, which had previously been seen in the bodies of Syrian terrorists.
– The representative of the Armenian Ministry of Defense, Artsrun Hovhannisyan, announced that the clashes have reached near the important Lachin border region. According to the representative of the Armenian Ministry of Defense, clashes between Armenian and Azerbaijani forces continue in the southern plains of the Lachin region.
– News sources report the death of an Armenian government official in Nagorno-Karabakh. According to reports, Armenian Minister of Emergency Situations and Deputy Prime Minister was killed in an airstrike on a convoy carrying Artsakh President Arayik Harutyunyan. News sources also say that Harutyunyan was seriously injured.
– According to the pro-Armenian media, one person was killed and two others were wounded in the bombardment of the Davit Bek region in Armenia by Azerbaijani artillery.