Tag: Erdogan

  • Putin and Erdogan Discuss about Idlib and Northern Syria, Meeting in Moscow

    Putin and Erdogan Discuss about Idlib and Northern Syria, Meeting in Moscow

    In a press briefing after the meeting, it was stated that Russia and Turkey had reached a new agreement on the issue of Idlib.

     

    One of these agreements is the establishment of a “Demilitarized Zone” in Idlib. This summer, Russia and Turkey in a similar meeting agreed on this particular issue, but it had not been implemented properly.

     

    The Russian president also supported the talks between the Damascus government and Kurdish leaders, saying that “If such steps will indeed be taken, it will be a positive change. It will help stabilize the situation in this troubled region of the Syrian state, which is currently under control of Kurdish forces”, he said.

     

    The Turkish president revealed that Washington had given positive signals regarding the creation of a “Safe Zone” in northeastern Syria, and noted that Russia has no problem with that.

    He also said that “Ankara and Moscow will continue their fight against terrorist groups in the province of Idlib”.

     

    The next Syria summit will be a trilateral summit between Moscow, Ankara and Tehran, which the exact date of this summit has not been announced yet.

  • Turkish Committee Visiting Moscow to Negotiation About Issues of North of Syria

    Turkish Committee Visiting Moscow to Negotiation About Issues of North of Syria

    On Friday Syrian Chief of Staff released a statement that Syrian Army entered Manbij; later Erdogan taking a harsh stand stated that Syrian Regime started a mental war in Manbij and demanded sides to avoid intriguing behavior.
    Erdogan stated that our goal is just to punish YPG and we do not plan to dissociate Syria and if terrorists threat is removed we do not have anything to do over there!

     

    Now all the attention are toward Moscow and the Turkish Committee to see their decision about Manbij and east of Euphrates River.

  • Have Syrian Army Entered the City of Manbij ?

    Have Syrian Army Entered the City of Manbij ?

    On Friday, The General Command of the Syrian Armed Forces, with publishing a statement, gave news about Syrian army forces entering the city of Manbij in northeast of Aleppo province

    An important news which led to a vast wave of reactions from media activists; but the truth is a little bit different from what is published in the news.

     

    The issue of SAA’s presence in regions, which are under the control of the Kurds around Manbij and eastern Euphrates, have a long history. The important point is that the Syria’s kurds have never destroyed all the bridges behind them for negotiating with Damascus, and the negotiations, despite its up and downs, have always been going on.

    Also during these past days because of the things that happened and the current changes in the region, Kurd’s negotiations with Damascus have entered in a new chapter and different than what have been going on before.

    Although the details of the negotiations have not been published officially, however, understanding it, based on field changes, is not a difficult task for those who follow the developments of Syria.

     

    It seems that agreement between the government and the Kurds will implemented in couple of stages and every stage will be dependant on joint decisions and according to existing capacities, and until it is executable.

     

    So in its first stage we witnessed the campaign of Syrian Army towards the town of Arimah in west of Manbij; during the many denies (that the SAA is not present) the SAA’s forces deployed in Arimah.

    Of course last year in March the SAA forces have been deployed in western countryside of Arimah in order to prevent the influence of Turkey’s militias, which back in those days they were advancing towards Arimah under the Turkish army’s operation called “Euphrates Shield”. so the presence of Syrian forces around Arimah was not a new subject, and isn’t.

     

    And in the second stage of agreement between Syrian government and the Kurds, the SAA forces have strongly began their next step towards entering the city of Manbij and they will  deploy in contact lines of Kurds (Manbij Military Council) with Turkey’s militias in northern areas of Manbij. the strong step of SAA is the published announcement of the General Command of the Syrian Armed Forces!

     

    Until the writing of this text (16:00, Friday), the SAA forces have not entered the city of Manbij, and all the news about the SAA forces entering the city is lie or incorrect.

    Today a delegation of Syrian and Russian forces entered the city and talked with “Manbij Military Council” members and left the city once the talks ended, but the SAA forces have not yet entered the city.

    Although the people in the city are hoisting the flag of Syria on the roof of their houses, and obviously the SAA will enter Manbij.

     

    In fact, The Syrian Armed Forces with publishing an official statement, saying that the army have entered Manbij, made Turkey and Erdogan to understand and warned them that the government is determined to take back the occupied regions, and the way for another foreigner to enter Syria is closed.

     

    So that was the reason that Erdogan today, after this news, stated that the SAA have began a psychological warfare inside of Manbij, and that the parties must not do provocative actions.

    He said that our goal is to give YPG a lesson, and we don’t want to disintegrate Syria, and if the threats from terrorist are neutralized, we are gone!

     

    On the other hand, the official account of YPG published a statement, saying that YPG forces have retreated(or will retreat) from western Euphrates and handed it to Syrian army.

    Maybe the Kurds have learned their lesson from Afrin…

     

    According to the information at hand, the further stages of the agreement between the Kurds and government, will include eastern Euphrates and the control of these regions will gradually goes back to government. Of course it is to soon to talk about this and the quality of its implementation, we must wait and see what happens.

  • Turkey Delays Its Operation in East of Euphrates, Syria

    Turkey Delays Its Operation in East of Euphrates, Syria

    He said that after the phone call we made with U.S. President Donald Trump, as well as the contacts of our diplomatic and security units, we decided to wait for a while and of course this is not an open ended waiting process.

     

    Erdogan said that Turkey has “no eyes” on Syria’s territory but our position against terrorist attacks targeting us from Syria is clear.

     

    He added that Turkey was obliged to take over the peacemaker role in Syria.

  • Erdogan: Turkey to start operation in east of Euphrates in few days

    Erdogan: Turkey to start operation in east of Euphrates in few days

    Erdogan said that Turkey’s target in Syria has never been U.S. troops, but rather the terrorists the U.S. has been working with, against Turkey’s strenuous objections.

    He added “Despite everything, if we meet on the right grounds, we see the U.S. as our strategic ally that we walk into the future with together; Turkey and the U.S. should not allow their “deep” disagreements over Syria to prevent major cooperation in the future.”

    Thus We will start the operation to clear the East of the Euphrates from separatist terrorists in a few days, he said.

     

    Following the announcement of Turkish operations in eastern Euphrates by the Turkish president, armored vehicles and more troops were transferred to the Syrian border; on the other hand, the United States has announced that it has established new surveillance posts near the Turkish borders to reduce any tensions in the area.

     

     

  • Turkey’s Erdogan mobilizing China’s Muslims for jihadist campaign + Clip

    Turkey’s Erdogan mobilizing China’s Muslims for jihadist campaign + Clip

    The clandestine web of networks that was set up by Turkey’s National Intelligence Organization (MİT) among Uyghurs and other Muslim groups from Central Asian countries involves not only transporting and facilitating jihadist fighters from China’s Xinxiang region, some of the fiercest and most battle-hardened militants who can only be compared to Russian’s Chechens on the field, but also mobilization of larger diaspora Uyghur groups in Turkey and abroad for a public relations campaign. It is quite a dangerous pattern in that Erdogan and his associates have been sowing the seeds of a jihadist mindset among Uyghurs with the support of state resources which at times manifested itself with the issuance of passports and travel documents and at other times with providing arms and logistical supplies.

     

    Last week we saw serious indications of how the radicalization of Uyghur communities in Turkey has already taken a toll, coming on the heels of war-frenzy campaign that was sanctioned and encouraged by the Turkish government with heavy doses of religious references repeatedly made by Erdogan himself. On March 10, 2018 some 700 Muslims from China visited the southeastern border city of Hatay near Syria and made an appearance in the provincial headquarters of Erdogan’s ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) to deliver the message that they wanted to join the battle in Afrin. Speaking on behalf of the group, Seyit Tümtürk, the chairman of the Eastern Turkistan Association for Culture and Solidarity (Doğu Türkistan Kültür ve Dayanışma Derneği in Turkish), said, “We want to fight in Afrin shoulder-to-shoulder with Turkish troops.”

     

    Sitting next to İbrahim Güler, the provincial chairman of the AKP and Erdogan’s man in Hatay, Tümtürk said, “The hearts of hundreds of thousands of people from Eastern Turkistan who live in Turkey today as well as 35 million in Eastern Turkistan [China’s Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region] are beating in sync with Turkey, the Turkish army and Turkish troops.” He asked AKP stooge Güler to convey the message to Erdogan that they are ready enlist in the Turkish army and fight alongside Turkish troops in Syria. He made clear that Muslims from Eastern Turkistan made the trip to the border city to send a message that China’s Muslims were putting themselves under the orders of commander-in-chief Erdogan and they were ready to sacrifice their lives for God and the Turkish nation once the signal is given by the Turkish president. The group later participated in a blood drive for the wounded in the Afrin offensive and visited the police special operations headquarters in Hatay.

     

     

    Another development that took place was in Istanbul on March 4, 2018 when a nationalist group called Alperenler, the youth wing of the Grand Unity Party (BBP), which is closely aligned with the Turkish president, held a rally with Uyghurs to display their support for the government. Appearing at the rally was Hidayet Oğuzhan, chairman of the Eastern Turkistan Education Association (Doğu Türkistan Maarif Derneği in Turkish), who vowed that “300,000 people from Eastern Turkistan will confront the evil axis that is attacking Turkey.” Underlining that China’s Muslims support the Turkish military offensive in Syria’s Afrin region, Oğuzhan stated that Turkey is the last bastion of the Islamic world and that all people from Eastern Turkistan are ready to sacrifice their lives to protect Turkey. “We do not want to be merely a voice for the more than 40-million-strong nation of ours that is being oppressed in Eastern Turkistan. That is, of course, our duty. But we are conscious of the most important goal today, which is to protect and preserve the Turkish state, a beacon of hope for the whole Muslim Ummah and the Turkish Islamic world and the last stronghold of Islam,” Oğuzhan told rally participants.

     

    All these protests and speeches were carried by Turkey’s state-run news agency Anadolu and covered by pro-Erdogan media outlets that help spread these messages to a broader audience. This looks like part of a well-planned public relations campaign orchestrated by Erdogan and his associates to imbue every segment of Turkish society with the extremist Islamist ideology that serves as a catalyst for jihadist networks in Turkey and abroad. No wonder China’s Muslims constitute the largest group of jihadist fighters in nominal terms who crossed into Syria and Iraq through Turkish territory with the help of Turkish intelligence.

     

    In fact, when the Turkish Meydan newspaper broke a story on April 9, 2015 about how a secret operation to provide Turkish passports to Uyghurs was run from a building in Istanbul’s Zeytinburnu district, apparently a covert operation of Turkish intelligence, it irritated the Erdogan government. The police raided the offices of the newspaper in July 2016, and the newspaper was later unlawfully shut down by the Erdoğan regime. Editor-in-Chief Levent Kenez was detained only to be released pending charges the next day. He fled Turkey before the government issued a fresh warrant for his arrest. The entire archive of the Meydan daily was removed by the government to get rid of any record and evidence of this nasty business with Uyghur jihadists.

     

    Turkish president Erdogan’s war-mongering narrative in public speeches in recent weeks and months reflects his tendency to describe his government’s proxy battles as religious holy wars. Perhaps this can only compare, to some degree, to what we hear and read from the leadership of al-Qaeda, the Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant (ISIL, ISIS or Daesh by its Arabic acronym). First, he repeatedly said the name of the military operation, “Olive Branch,” was inspired by references from the Muslim holy book, the Quran. For example, on Feb. 9, 2018 he told neighborhood leaders (muhtars) in his own palace that he was inspired to name the Afrin military offensive Operation Olive from the Quran and recited verse 95:1, which mentions “olive.”  On March 10 he repeated the same claim and even went further by reciting the rest of the verses of Chapter 95, which mentioned the secure city, a reference to the Saudi Arabian city of Makkah. He said his troops are marching toward the secure city with God’s permission, which would certainly disturb Saudi Arabian rulers.

     

    On March 7 Erdogan again recited Quran verses from Chapter 61 and said: “Know this. We were ordered to wage a [war] campaign [by God], the victory belongs to Allah. And don’t forget this. What is Allah saying in His [Quran] verses? Help from Allah and imminent victory.” The next day, in a speech delivered on the occasion of International Women’s Day, Erdogan vowed to acquire advanced military hardware including nuclear missiles while comparing Turkish military capabilities to those of the US military. He claimed Turkey has God on its side and that his people march for martyrdom, unlike Americans. He asked women to have at least three children to make Turkey more powerful and said that “the West will scramble to find a hiding place if we increase our young population.” The West is in decline, we need to gain more strength, he added.

     

    It is obvious that the world is confronted with a dangerous and fanatical leader who has set his sights on the caliph position of embattled ISIL leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi and is set to destabilize his neighbors and other countries using proxy Islamist groups. This is not just poisonously anti-Western but in fact is anti-Asian as well because of threats that risk undermining social cohesion in the communities of Russia, China and other Asian countries. Not only the narrative but also the policy choices of Erdogan in the current government of Turkey increasingly reflect his ambitions to portray himself as the leader of all Muslims in the world. The only difference is that Erdogan, unlike Baghdadi, commands NATO’s largest army after the US and enjoys the considerable resources of the Turkish state.

     

    Unfortunately, the checks and balances against his autocratic rule have all but collapsed, while the opposition is in disarray. Scrutiny by the national media no longer exists as some 200 media outlets were shuttered and 250 journalists jailed. The criminal justice system fails to prosecute jihadist groups thanks but no thanks to pressure from the Erdogan government, which has purged one-third of all judges and prosecutors since 2016. Credit is due to the government’s helper, Doğu Perinçek, who leads a neo-nationalist group in empowering Erdogan’s rule and in aiding and abetting the unprecedented crackdown on Erdogan’s critics, especially members of the Gülen movement, who unwaveringly stood firm against his oppressive rule despite bearing the brunt of the unrelenting repression. Incidentally, it is quite ironic to see Perinçek ostensibly cozying up to the Chinese Communist Party leadership in Beijing when in fact his own clandestine group in the intelligence and military has been organizing Uyghurs to join jihadist causes.


    By Abdullah Bozkurt

    Turkishminute.com

  • “Everyone knows that the Turks do not leave easily from where they entered”

    “Everyone knows that the Turks do not leave easily from where they entered”


    Threatened with death by salafi jihadists, Fehim Taştekin also undergoes several prosecutions in Turkey for his articles on the Syrian crisis and on president Erdoğan, who he carefully follows since the 1990’s from within the Islamic movement. He now lives in exile, where I met him.


     

    • Since 20th January, the Turkish army is conducting a vast ground and air offensive in the region of Afrin, one of the Rojava’s three autonomous region. Why?

    This is related to the Kurdish question and to the Turkish government’s obessionnal plan for Syria. Since 2011, Erdoğan  has made many mistakes because of which many jihadist groups haves emerged and established themselves in our region. Moreover, he failed in overthrowing Assad and installing the Muslim Brotherhood. He had to intervene to stay in the game and prevent the formation of a Kurdish-lead autonomous region in north Syria (Rojava), of which Afrin is the most western part.

     

    Already in 2016, while the “Euphrates Shield operation”, the Turkish army halted the advance of the People’s Protection Units (YPG), the defense force of the ‘de facto’ autonomous region (Rojava)  who sought to link Kobane and Afrin. This success allowed  Erdoğan to gain influence on the Syrian chessboard. Russia, Iran, the United States understood that they had to take Turkey into account.

    By launching the “Olive Branch” operation in early 2018, the Turkish President is pursuing the same logic: The consolidation of his influence on the negotiation process. He also wants to break down the alliance between the USA and the YPG.

     

    If Turkish troops succeed in Afrin, the next step will be an offensive on Manbij, where there are american units. This was at the center of discussions between Secretary of State Rex Tillerson and President  Erdoğan during their meeting  on Thursday 15 February in Ankara.

     

    • In the past, the Afrin authorities seem to have avoided any confrontation with Turkey. Why is the Turkish government aiming this region precisely?       

     Afrin is a Kurdish area, inhabited mostly by Kurds since at least a thousand years. After 1980, while Abdullah Öcalan, the leader of the PKK [detained by Turkey since 1999], lived in Syria, he was very active in the Kobane, Aleppo (Sheikh Maksud area) and Afrin regions, where Kurds became mostly “Öcalanists”. Here one must be careful: Being an Öcalanist does not mean automatically being member of the PKK. Nevertheless Afrin’s Kurds adhered to many of Öcalan’s ideas.

     

    In cooperation with some members of the Assad family and the regime, Öcalan has created many collectivist cooperatives in Afrin, for example for the cultivation of olives, making olive oil and soap, and setting up transportation chains around Syria. These cooperatives helped local communities work together. The region of Afrin became a sort of applied laboratory of Öcalan’s ideas. This is also what the Turkish government is targeting. While having problems with other Kurdish parties Öcanalist movement had good contacts with ethnic or religious communities in the region like Arabs, Circassians, Chechens, Armenians or Yezidis (Kurds).

     

    Afrin is a strong base of the Öcalanist movement and of the Democratic Union Party (PYD), it is why Turkey will face a fierce resistance. The government says: “We are not fighting against Kurds but a terrorist organization”. But the fact is that the local population supports widely the PYD and its allies in the autonomous project. And even those who do not support this party, take up arms to protect their land. This is why one should not compare the PYD and the Islamic State (IS). The Kurds are fighting for defending their land, their homes, while most of the IS jihadists were foreigners, it is very different. People are aware that they have faced two projects which are absolutely opposite each other. So the one is bringing darkness back with its all forms, the other is offering to share powers, participating to democratic processes, getting women into social and political spheres, securing all ethnic and religious identities. Since 20th January, 31 Turkish soldiers and 194 fighters of the Free Syrian Army died. Things are not going as well as Erdoğan had announced.

     

    • On the ground, the remaining forces of the Free Syrian Army (FSA) fight on the side of Turkey. A British newspaper reported that many of its soldiers were former IS jihadists… Has Turkey got jihadist partners?

    Many different groups are taking part in this military operation. Some of those include former Al-Qaeda members, Salafi jihadists and a variety of Islamists such as the Muslim Brotherhood, mercenaries and some volunteers. What unites them is their unfavorable attitudes and ideologies towards the Kurds.

     

    Besides this, the Islamic-nationalist power of Erdoğan has created its own militia. There is a private security company, called SADAT, which trains, equips and advises fighters who fight on behalf of Turkey.

     

    SADAT, composed of former Turkish soldiers, gained in prominence during the Syrian crisis. The budget and weapons that are devolved to this organization is top secret. We do not know how it is financed.

     

    Last month, we saw a picture of Adnan Tanriverdi, former Turkish officer and owner of SADAT, beside Turkish generals in the National Security Council meeting for the Afrin operation. He participated to this meeting without having any official status. This is unusual and very problematic for the orientation given to the national security  and to the state tradition of Turkey.

     

    • You mentioned links between the Kurdish PKK and the Assad regime. What about them?

    In 1990, the PKK succeeded in sending six “independent” deputies to the Syrian parliament. All came from Afrin. Some of those were directly members of the PKK, others were only “patriots” (Yurtsever) who are not member of PKK but supporting it indirectly. In that election the number of seats had left for independents increased from 18 to 40 percent. This assumed an ‘olive branch’ for Kurds by the regime that time. With this system a total of 15 Kurds could enter the parliament. With the fear of losing control, the old system was re-established at the 1994 election. The Afrin Kurds were essentially “patriots” (Yurtsever) and have always been close to Damascus.

     

    However, in Jazeere the relations between the Kurds and the Syrian regime were getting more tense. Because of the Arab Belt Project (1962), the land of many Kurds was confiscated and civil rights of 120.000 Kurds were revoked after the 1961 census. Because of that some 350.000 Kurds did not have any identity card or passport until 2011.

    Otherwise, the Syrian regime tolerated the PKK as long as they fought for the Bakur [Turkish part of Kurdistan], as this was a weapon that the Damascus regime could use against Turkey.

     

    Things changed only after the Adana Agreement of 1998 and the deportation of Öcalan out of Syria [he was arrested in 1999 by Turkish and Israeli services in Nairobi].

     

    In Syria, the Democratic Union Party (PYD) emerged in 2003. Influenced by Öcalan’s ideas (establishment of self-governed communities, emancipation of women…), the PYD presents himself as a party fighting for democracy in Syria. Hence a less tolerant stance of the Syrian government towards it.

     

    Quickly, after the 2011 uprising, the Syrian government withdrew from the northern part of the country or directly gave the control of some provinces to the PYD. There are several reasons for that. First, the PYD is an organized and known structure with which one can anticipate and negotiate. Second, this kept Kurds outside the uprising, and Damascus wanted to focus on the central hubs of contestations which where strategically more important. Third, it was also a message to Turkey: ““If you support Islamist groups against me, you will have to face a Kurdish autonomous region on your border”.

     

    • At the beginning, until 2015, things were not going so badly between Ankara and the PYD – its copresident, Salih Muslim, visited Turkey several times…

     Yes, he was invited in Istanbul and Ankara many times. Even more amazingly, a couple of leaders of YPG exchanged in Ankara with Turkish generals. They prepared a joint operation together to move the Suleyman Shah Tomb Tomb to the Eshme, a closer point to  the Turkish frontier. This was a unique relationship, and some believed that it would have a positive impact on the peace negotiations between Ankara and the PKK. But after that, Ankara named the PYD a “terrorist organisation” and placed a bounty of 4 millions of TL (more than 850.000 euros) for the arrest of Salih Muslim.

     

    To understand this sudden change, one must take account of the broader peace negotiations with Öcalan. The Turkish authorities made of Rojava issue a pre-condition of the peace process. Through Öcalan, Ankara asked three things to the Syrian Kurds: To end the Rojava as ‘de facto autonomy’; to cooperate with the Free Syrian Army and to fight the Assad regime. Öcalan refused these conditions making Rojava his “red line” too.

     

    The attitude of Erdoğan during the siege of Kobane (autumn 2014) repeating that Kobane was to the point of falling in Daish hands, the fact he didn’t close the roads to the Daish militants, and close his eyes on the militants or materials transfer, legal or illegal: All these led to an outburst of anger in the Turkish Kurdistan, in which dozens of people lost their lives.

     

    After that, the Peoples’ Democratic Party (HDP) [the Turkish and Kurdish pro-autonomy party] declared that it would oppose the presidential dreams of Erdoğan. This is why, in summer 2015, Erdoğan launched a war against Kurds: in Turkey and in Syria.

     

    • Didn’t the Kurdish HDP leaders in Turkey, or the PKK leaders in Qandil (Irak) share some of the responsibility for the failure of these negotiations? Do you believe that the PKK has provoked this uprising?

    Of course, the Kurdish movement made some mistakes and provided excellent arguments to Erdoğan. In some cities like Diyarbakır, Kurdish youths dug trenches and closed streets. Some HDP mayors declared the democratic autonomy.

     

    But there was no massive popular uprising. Some youths gave a pretext to Erdoğan which was looking for launching a strong operation on the Kurdish movement, its municipalities and NGO.  Some HDP deputies were even not happy at all with the youth’s behavior in the streets for it happened these youths had arrested some deputies to control their identity!

     

    On the 22d of July 2015, two policemen were killed. The PKK first claimed it in retaliation to the massacre conducted by the Islamic State two days before in Suruç (30 people killed). Later on PKK denied.

    It was the perfect pretext for Erdoğan to launch his operation against the Kurdish towns. Some neighborhoods were fully or partly torn to the ground, hundreds of thousands of people were displaced. The goal was to completely paralyze and destroy the HDP (who had 80 MP in June 2015, 59 five months later). Thousands of officials and volunteers of the party were arrested. Erdoğan acted with a terrifying brutality.

     

    The Kurdish movement did not expect such a reaction. Öcalan could have dissuaded young people of going into the streets as he did in 2013, but the state isolated Öcalan during the crisis and did not let him address his people. The PKK leaders decided not to intervene, saying that the “youths are acting on their initiative”. They probably believed that if they diverted the attention of the government to the north, it would leave Rojava alone. It was a mistake.

    In 2016, the Kurdistan Freedom Hawks (TAK), a PKK affiliate according to the Turkish State, conducted terror attacks in Istanbul, Ankara, Izmir and Bursa to take revenge of the massacres and destructions by the Turkish security forces in the south-east of Turkey since July 2015.

     

    • According to Turkish authorities, the PYD in Syria and the PKK, forbidden in Turkey, is the same thing: two terrorist organizations…

    In Syrian, the Democratic Union Party (PYD) follows the ideas of Öcalan. The core leaders of the PYD are linked to the PKK. However, one cannot say that it is the same thing. Most of the youths which fight in the YPG didn’t come from PKK and didn’t participate to the PKK camps. Many PYD members do not have any  organizational  links with the PKK.

     

    On many points, the PYD looks closer to the  Peoples’ Democratic Party (HDP). HDP was also founded on the ideas on Öcalan. Their strategy is the same: they believe that in order to guarantee rights for the minorities, it is necessary to democratize the whole country.

     

    However, the HDP is less monolithic than the PYD. The HDP is a coalition of many movements: around the Kurdish Democratic Region Party (DBP) more than thirty left wing and ecological organizations are agglomerated, while on the other hand, thought the PYD has a few minor partners, it is accused of imposing a “single party regime”.

     

    • The Turkish government wants to break the alliance between the PYD and the USA and make sure that the de facto Kurdish autonomy will never be recognized de jure. What are its chances of success?

    Turkey can disturb calculations of other players up to a point but at the end of the day it will gain nothing except enmity between Kurds and Turks.

    The aggressive policy of Turkey in Syria strongly affects Turkish Kurds who have very strong ties with Syrian Kurds. Turkish Kurds are as shocked by the attack of Afrin as they would if Diyarbakir itself was attacked. The Turkish government will not be able to erase the enmity that it has itself created. While, by supporting an autonomous Kurdish zone in Syria, he could have more easily solved the Kurdish problem, since the PKK and the PYD are interlinked.

     

    Moreover,  Erdoğan  does not hide that he wants to send back a few thousand of the three millions million Syrian Arab refugees that Turkey has welcomed. This would overturn the demographic balance at the expense of Kurds. This ethnic cleansing will be perceived as a “genocide” by all Kurds.

     

    • Regarding “ethnic cleansing”, YPG-PYD Kurds also have been deporting Arab populations and confiscating their land…

    Yes, they have been accused of “ethnic cleansing” during the Operation against IS in Tel Abyad (Rakka province). YPG have made mistakes by destroying houses used as shelters by IS soldiers and demanding some villagers to evacuate of their houses. But I would not say that any intentional ethnic cleansing took place…

    Some measures were temporary bases and after securing areas people started to come back if they have not links to the ISIS. During the war thousands settlements were destroyed because of bombings and their settlers fled in Syria.

     

    Erdoğan has used a report of Amnesty International (2015), very critical on YPG-PYD Kurds, but it was grounded on unreliable and hastily collected information in early stage of the case…  After the victory over IS, Kurds of Tel Abyad have established a civil council to govern the town with Arabs and Turkmens. It means they didn’t exclude Arabs and Turkmens as Turkey insisted.

     

    • What is the position of Russia and the USA on the Turkish military offensive in Afrin, and more broadly, on the Kurdish problem?

    Russia hopes that thanks to this operation, the YPG will turn away from the United States and cooperate with the Syrian regime. In exchange of Afrin, Russia is expecting a strong cooperation from Turkey to neutralize Islamist and jihadist groups in Idlib.  But what Erdoğan is going to do is unclear. He tends to protect fighters in Idlib that are one of the main targets of Russia.

     

    If Turkey takes the control of Afrin it will connect Idlib to the Azez-Cerablus-Al Bab triangle under the control of the Turkish and Free Syrian Army (FSA), which represents another leverage in the hands of Erdoğan and will help the militants against Assad in Idlib. Russia will probably not appreciate it.

    However, Moscow, which is always keen to weaken NATO, would not be displeased to see Erdoğan evoke an extension of operations to Manbij, which will push the Americans (allied to the YPG-PYD against Daish) to choose their side: “The Kurds or us”.

     

    It seems that in Ankara, 15 February, Tillerson and Erdoğan discussed the withdrawal of YPG troops from Manbij. In exchange for this city, the USA could try transforming the east of the Euphrates into a secured autonomous Kurdish zone. But this is the opposite of the end of Rojava that Erdoğan promised to his electorate. I do not know how he will defend this deal in front of his people.

    • Iranian Shiite militias are now strongly established in Iraq, Syria and Lebanon… but what are the relations between Tehran and the PYD-PKK ?

    At the beginning of the Syrian crisis, the Kurdistan Free Life Party (PJAK, PKK’s Iranian branch) and Iran concluded a ceasefire. Iran saw the Kurdish potential in Syria and the necessity of “neutralizing” them to prevent them to take part in the conflict.

    Iran does not object a form of Kurdish autonomy in Syria as long as it does not distort the territorial integrity of the country. As Russians, Iranians foremost desire to see Kurds collaborate with Damascus and stay far from Americans. If Kurds line up with the American ambitions in the region, Iranian proxy forces will probably join the Syrian forces which fight them.

     

    In addition, Iran is concerned with the Turkish intervention in Syria. It is well known that Turks don’t get out easily from where they enter. As for Moscow, it is unacceptable for Teheran to see Turkey support radical groups fighting the regime in Idlib. On 11th January 2018, Turkish backed groups started an operation against the Syrian army and the Hezbollah around the Abu Duhur airbase for instance.

     

    To make things more complex, while Turkey, Iran and Russia are partners in the Astana process, it happens on the ground that some groups supported by the Iranians sided with the Kurds. For Iran try to persuade the Kurds not to align with the United States. Otherwise “We’ll leave the Turks to crush you” tells Tehran. Russia and Iran could give Kurds a autonomy status in Syria as for Kurds forget the United States.

     

    The red line of Russia and Iran is the American presence alongside the Kurds. And the Kurds crossed this line at Raqqa, Deir al Zor and when the Americans wanted to build a Kurdish border army. This immediately led Russia to allow Turkey to intervene on Afrin to try to hinder the Americans.

     

    • While many commentators evoke the perspective of the next presidential election of Novembre 2019 to explain  Erdoğan’s  military activism in Syria, you seem to minimize this motivation…

    I do not exclude the internal factors. Of course, Erdoğan must consolidate his base and secure votes from nationalist circles for the 2019 election and for this, nothing is better than a victory over Kurdish “terrorists”.

    But reducing this operation to internal policy considerations is irrelevant. Erdoğan did not abandon his Syrian dream, his neo-Ottoman dream. He sees himself not only as the President of Turkey but as the President of the Islamic world, and he acts in this way. This dream does not make sense if you do not have Damascus with you. Without Damascus you cannot do anything in the Arab world.

     

    It reminds me of the Conference of the Syrian Opposition in Exile held in Istanbul in 2011 to which I was invited to speak. Ahmet Ağırakça, a Turkish academic took the floor. “Inshallah” he said, “After the liberation of Damascus, will come the turn of Jerusalem and ‘The Term First Erdoğan’  will come”. This was ridiculous and totally disproportionate, no one in the Arab world is waiting for a new Ottoman Sultan. But it shows the existence of such a neo-Ottoman project for many Turks. This academic is now the dean of Mardin Artuklu University.

     

    • You left Turkey like more than a hundred of your colleagues, according to Reporters sans frontières…

    Unfortunately, Turkey became an unsafe country for many journalists and writers. I am in an uneasy situation because of my articles and books on the Syrian crises. I have received some death threats from Turkish and Syrian jihadist groups. Besides, one of my books (Rojava: Time of Kurds) was confiscated as a criminal evidence against several defendants who have been arrested for participating to peace demonstrations or sending messages on social media.

     

    Finally, last summer, a Turkish court banned Rojava: Time of Kurds. The court called my book a “terrorist organisation” in its judgment. How can a juridical system consider a book as a “terrorist organisation” ?

     

    The two opposition parties, the Republican People’s Party (CHP) and People’s Democratic Party (HDP) have submitted parliamentary questions on this ban. And I am under investigation for my articles, books and social messages about the state and  Erdoğan. Message of threats against me and my family never cease. This means that we are not in security anymore in our own country.

     


    Interview with Fehim Taştekin conducted by Ariane Bonzon

  • Latest map of fronts in Syria until 13 February 2018

    Latest map of fronts in Syria until 13 February 2018

    Latest HD map of fronts in Syria: download

    Map of 105 days ago for comparison: Here


    ?The most important changes during the last 105 days as follows:

     

    East of Syria:

    After liberation of Abu Kamal in 19 November 2017, a few villages between Abu Kamal and Salehiya and from Salehiya to al-Mayadin on the southern bank of Euphrates river are liberated by Moghawemah and Syrian Army troops thus the remaining bases of ISIS fall in east of Syria and ISIS are besieged in an area of 7,200 km2 in east of Homs and south of Deir ez Zor.

    After that to secure Abu Kamal, some of the deserts until Mu`ayzilah dam are also cleared up. This achievement happens after troops present in T2 area move toward north and Mu`ayzilah dam and some other troops join them from northern axis toward Mu`ayzilah and liberate the besieged area of about 2,000 km2.

     

    South of Syria

    The most important change in south of Syria is indeed the liberation of occupied areas by militia in strategic region of Beit Jin.

    In the last several years, these areas were safe place of terrorists and with the support of Israel and Jordan, by moving from Daraa to Qalamoun using the connecting roads and valleys, they were a serious threat to Damascus.

    After the operation in last year and liberation of Khan al Shih area in south of Damascus, several committees tried to negotiate with militia in Beit Jinn to avoid any bloodshed to liberate these areas and not harm civilian lives but they did not accept never or demanded out of question privileges.

    Finally in December 2018 when militia using obvious helps of Israel and using their observing posts detoured Syrian Army positions in Hadhar area using occupied Golan and attacked Hadhar to break the siege of Beit Jinn, Syrian Army follows the operation in Beit Jin with more determination and by defending militia attacks, increase their advances.

    The operation carried out using carrot and stick behavior and at each stage, Syrian Army using military activities and negotiations succeed to remove all the militia and their families from Beit Jin area and to raise Syrian flag on the heights and in January 2018, Beit Jin officially rejoins Syria again.

     

    Northwest of Syria

    As predicted by finishing ISIS in east of Syria (except some desert areas), the attentions and operations are now on Idlib and Hama governorates; therefor after implementing of the “de-escalation zone” plan in northwest of Syria and Turkish forces’ penetration to west of Idlib and Hama governorates, the operation of Syrian and Moghawemah forces in northeast of Hama and northern axis of Sa`an and Sheikh Hilal and inside Idlib governorate starts.

    In the region they advance from several axis; Moghawemat from Khanser and northeast of Hama and Syrian Army from north of Hama toward Abu Dohur airbase could liberate a vast area in a month.

    Overall liberated area from ISIS between Idlib, Aleppo and Hama governorates adds up to near 3,500 km2.

    Click here to Download the video of final steps of operation.

     

    Afrin area

    The other significant change is invasion of Afrin by Turkey and their militants.

    After the latest of Syrian Peace Talks in Astana which held with presence of different sides in Syria, Russian, Turkish and Iranian officials to investigate the situation of “de-escalation zone” plan, some Turkish troops establish in Idlib and south of Afrin area according to this agreement.

    But after Moghawemah and Syrian Army advances in northwest of Syria, which was according to the areas of “de-escalation zone” agreement as well, using some excuses and preemption, Erdogan invades Afrin.

    An attack which was not agreed on in the peace talk…

     

    Turkish operation condition is a mixture of Erdogan’s opportunity, Russian distraint, Kurdish and Moghawemat’s stubbornness and passivity, nevertheless Turkish invasion in Afrin is changing the area and if they occupy it completely, its impact on political future of Syria is inevitable and harsh.

     

    Further information can be found in the article “Russian game, Turkish opportunism and Iranian passivity in the north of Syria”

  • News on Operation Olive Branch tenth day; 29 January 2018

    News on Operation Olive Branch tenth day; 29 January 2018

    FSA in the evening of 28 January could occupy Qastal jondu and Yazi Bagh in the east of Afrin. They also enter Kawir Kar hill, there are heavy engagements on this hill and Kurdish forces claim to defend it. ANHA news claim that Kurdish troops recapture Qastal Jondu. There are reports of heavy fights in Maranaz, Kurds claim to destroy a tank near it. While Turkish commanders press conference was supposed to hold over Mount Barsaya today, due to unknown reasons it has been canceled.

     

    In western front, Faylaq al Awwal and Samarqan brigade forces could capture Hamam village and move engagements to southern heights of the village, after fantastic nine days of Kurds brave defense. Faylaq al Awwal and Sultan Muhamad Fateh brigade forces could also occupy village of Ma`amel Oshaghi very recently. FSA claiming capture of 915 height near Rajo. Therefore, if Kurdish forces do not want to urban fight, the village fall is very possible. In visual news broadcasting today, it is obvious that Turkish infantry are not participating in advances.

     

    According to official report of Turkish Army in 28 January, 27 fighters participate in bombing different points in Afrin. According to this report until the end of 28 January, 597 “terrorists” are killed.

     

    In all the reports by Turkey, the death casualties include both YPG and ISIS forces! This is while ISIS is not present in northern Aleppo from 2016.

     

    Turkey treats criticizers of Operation Olive Branch with iron fist, some examples are as follows:

    1. Arresting 300 protesters in cyber space not in the streets.
    2. Filing a complaint by Ministry of State of Turkish Medical Association due to condemning the operation.
    3. Erdogan accuses Republican People’s Party (CHP) to be in alliance with PKK since they accused Erdogan of abusing Operation Olive Branch for his own benefits.

    This is while CHP has supported Operation Olive Branch before.

     

    Erdogan says: “If God wants we reach Idlib !”

     

    About the claim of Erdogan, Turkish Army activities are severe in Idlib governorate. In report of 27 January, it was said that a Turkish Convoy containing six armored vehicles entered Idlib evening of 26 January. According to reporters close to Tahrir al Sham, four of these vehicles are observed in southeastern front of Idlib near Abu Dohur, these sources report that the mission of this team is to examine the region in order to erect inspection posts in an agreement to reduce stresses with Russia.

     

    While Erdogan does not allow any reporter to enter Afrin, the first western reporter enters Afrin from Syrian Army side.

     

    Robert Fisk reporter of “Independent” publishing painful images of dead civilians writes:

    “The main victims of Turkish assault to Afrin are refugees, children and women.”

     

    In the tenth day of the operation, it can be said that Kurds have not published any image or video to support their claims including using napalm bombs to destroying helicopters or tanks.

     

    Turkish Airforce which destroyed a historical Armenian church before, destroys a famous Roman amphitheater today.

     

    Kamal Clichdar Oghlo leader of opposite party of CHP announces to establish a connection line between Damascus and Ankara travels to Damascus.

     

    According to Kurdish sources, during the air raid to Gobli village in 28 January so far eight civilians are killed and seven are injured. It is said that ten are under collapses.

     

    The role of economy in politics:

    • Is there any relation between “poor oil” condition of Afrin canton and the lack of US support of YPG in this canton?
    • Is there any relationship between the contract signed last December between Russia and Turkey to buy S400 SAMs which resulted in NATO concerns and Russian retreat from Afrin?
  • Turkey’s Afrin campaign; high risk of conflict in northwestern Syria; US establishes army entitled “Syrian Border Security Force”

    Turkey’s Afrin campaign; high risk of conflict in northwestern Syria; US establishes army entitled “Syrian Border Security Force”

    In the last few days that USA announces that they are going to establish a new military unit entitles “Syrian Border Security Force” to defend northern borders, Erdogan announces that he will activate Afrin front again.

     

    Ryan Dillon, Spokesman for Combined Joint Task Force led by USA regarding Syrian Border Security Force says that this unit consists of 30,000 troops, from which half are Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) will settle not only in northern borders but also in all borders such as border between Iraq and Syria and in Euphrates valley and in neighboring of Syrian Army.

    This clearly shows US plan to set borders for a new self-rule region in Syria.

     

    Publicization of this plan makes strong reactions of Russia and Turkey and Erdogan announces clearly that Turkish Army will attack Afrin and clear this area from PYD/PKK soon.

     

    The issue of Kurds in northern Syria and US supports and establishment of SDF whose main troops are from PYD/PKK is a big disagreement between USA and Turkey which is getting more severe every day and affects the relations between two countries.

     

    After the latest Syrian Peace Talks in Astana which took place with representatives of engaged groups in Syria and Russian, Turkish and Iranian officials to determine the situation of some less critical in Syria, some of Turkish troops based on this agreement settle in Aleppo governorate and south of Afrin from last month.

     

    From yesterday and after Erdogan claims new operation in Afrin, Turkish troops in Al Ra’i and Al Bab are transported toward Afrin fronts and according to news, more Turkish troops and armored vehicles are sent to Hatay and borders north of Afrin.

    All the evidences show more activities by Turkish Army near Afrin to operate soon.

    There are news that Turkish artilleries fire on PYD positions in southern Afrin from last night.

  • Double attack to Erdogan

    Double attack to Erdogan

    At the same time, Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu leader of Republican People’s party, the biggest opposition party in Turkish Parliament, accused Erdogan’s relatives and dependents that they transferred 15 million USD out of Turkey under a company to evade tax. Kılıçdaroğlu also claimed that he has all the swift evidences of these transactions.

    These allegations are so heavy that Erdogan said if they are proved he will resign from power otherwise Kılıçdaroğlu must resign. Erdogan also claimed that Zarrab’s statements are fake and the court is just a game. He also mentioned that Kılıçdaroğlu’s allegations are conducted by Abdullah Gülen.

    Now Erdogan’s hopes are on two matters inside Turkey:

    • His traditional followers who are a big portion of religious people in Turkey.
    • Justice system of Turkey which after the coup in 2016 was altered to be dependent to him mainly. As if this situation happened before 2016 coup, political life of Erdogan would be in jeopardy.